Fabian Tract No. 153. THE TWENTIETH CENTURY REFORM BILL. BY HENRY H. SCHLOESSER. PUBLISHED AND SoLD BY THE FABIAN SOCIETY. PRICE ONE PENNY. LONDON: THE FABIAN SociETY, 3 CLEMENT's I NK, S TRAND, W.C . ] ANUARY1 I9II. FIFTH EDITION. JusT PuBLISHED. WHAT TO READ ON SOCIAL AND ECONOMIC SOBJECTS. AN UP·TO-DATE, SELECT BIBLIOGRAPHY, DEALING WITH SocrALI!lM, Soc iAL AND INDUSTRIAL PROBLEM!>, EcoNOMICS AND EcoNoMIC HisTORY, PoLITICAL SCIENCE, GovERNMENT AND E:o;GLISH HrsTORY. Compiled by the Fabian Society for Students of University Extension Lectures and Classes, for persons investigating Social Problems, and for the general reader. Interleaved, in Paper Cover, 1s. net; bound in Buckram, 2s. net; postage 2d. THE FABIAN SOCIALIST SERIES. The first four volumes consist of a revised, collected, and classified edition of some of the most valuable of the famous " Fabian Tracts" in a style more suitable for the generalreading public. The booklets usually contain about g6 well- printed pages, good paper and good type, and is supplied in two forms ; in attractive wrappers at 6d. each, nett, and in quarter cloth boards, gilt top, at 1/-each, nett. Postage : 1d. and 2d. each. VOLUMES NOW READY : I. SOCIALISM AND RELIGION. CONTENTS: (1) Christian Socialism, by the Rev. Stewart D. Headlam. \2) Socialism and Christianity, by the Rev. Percy Dearmer. (3) Socialism and the Teaching of Christ, by the Rev. J ohn Clifford. (4) A Word of Remembrance and Caution to the Rich, by John Woolman. II. SOCIALISM AND AGRICULTURE. CONTENTS: (1) The Village and the Landlord, by Edward Carpenter. (2) State Aid to Agriculture, by T. S. Dymond. (3) The Secret of R ural Depopulation, by Lieut.-Col. D . C. Pedder. (4) The Revival of Agriculture, by the Fabian Eociety. III. SOCIALISM AND INDIVIDUALISM. CONTENTS: (1) The Difficulties of Individualism, by SidneyWebb. (2) The Moral Aspects of Socialism, by Sidney Ball. (3) The Impossibilities of Anarchism, by G. Bernard Shaw. (4) Public Service v. Private Expenditure, by Sir Oliver Lodge. IV. THE BASIS AND POLICY OF SOCIALISM. CONTENTS: (1) Facts for Socialists, by The Fabian Society. (2) Oapital and Land, by The Fabian Society. (3) Socialism: True and False, by Sidney Webb. (4) Twentieth Century Politics, by Sidney Webb. V. THE COMMONSENSE OF MUNICIPAL TRADING. By Beroard Shaw. With new Preface. VI. SOCIALISM AND NATIONAL MINIMUM. By Mrs. Sidney Webb, Miss B. L. Hutchins, and others. VII. WASTAGE OF CHILD LIFE. By J. Johnston, M.D. A sturly of Lancashire towns. VIII. SOCIALISM AND SUPERIOR BRAINS. By Bernard Shaw. With new portrait of the author. London: THE FABIAN SOCIET ·r"'3 fiiDe nn, Strand, W . II A1 /-roo /X I'-' (\ (!, ( THE TWENTIETH CEN1'URY REFORM BILL. P REPARED BY HENRY H. ScHLOESSER WITH THE AssiSTANCE oF A COMMITTEE APPOINTED FOR THE PURPOSE BY THE EXECUTIVE CoMMITTEE oF THE FABIAN SocmTv. INTRODUCTION . THE first draft of this measure was issued by the Fabian Society as Tract No. 14" "The New Reform Bill," exactly twenty years ago. No single one of the reforms then advocated has since become law ; but at the present moment (January, 19Il) the prospects of Electoral Reform are brighter than for many years past, and some of the proposals of our Bill are definitely promised by the first Cabinet within living memory which can reckon on fulfilling its promi;es without the concurrence of the UpperHouse. The present Bill, redrafted throughout and altered in many details (especially bythe substitution of the Alternative Vote for the Second Ballot), is intended as a complete scheme of Electoral Reform, with the exceptions noted below. It therefore includes Adult Suffrage and completely removes all existing sex disqualifications in connection with parliamentary elections. It permits women, married or single, to vme for and to be members of parliament as well as all minor governing bodies. But it should be pointed out that the advocacy of Adult Suffrage in this Tract is not intended to prejudice the highly controversial question whether at the present time the enfranchisement of women should be sought by such partial measures as conferring the parliamentary vote on some or all of the women at present qualified to vote for local governing bodies, or whether nothing less than Adult Suffrage should be accepted. This is a question of immediate parliamentary tactics which is outside the scope of the scheme here outlined. Since the time of the Chartist agitation, no attempt has been made to formulate a thorough scheme for the reform of the laws regulating our electoral system, if the confused, inconsistent, and often unintelligible mass of Acts of Parliament on the statute book can be dignified by such a name. From the Statute of Edward I., establishing freedom of election, down to the Registration Act, 1908, there have been over one hundred and sixty Acts to regulate the franchise, registration of electors, :md procedure at elections, etc. ; of which more than one hundred and twenty have been enacted since the passing of the Reform Act of 1832-a measure intended by Lord John Russell to settle finally the question of reform. With the single exception of the Corrupt and Illegal Practices Act (1883), n~ attempt has been made to codify any section of electoral law. One Act of Parliament contradicts another, and a reverence for antiquated modes of draughtsmanship has only made confusion worse confounded. A vote is given to every male householder~ only to be taken away from him by a cumbrous and iniquitous system of registration. with a long term of qualification, and an intentionally complex arrangement of claim. objection, and revision. 4 It is often said that the points of the People's Charter have been embodied in En~lish law ; but, as a matter of fact, the ballot alone has been adopted in its entuety. The suffrage has been considerably lowered, and some approach was made, twenty-five years ago, to the establishment of equal electoral districts, but the payment of members and a reduction in the duration of parliament are still promises for the future, though now more likely to be realized than ever before. The abolition of a property qualification for members has been largely a nominal reform, and can onlybe rendered effective by the payment of election expenses. In the following draft bill, an attempt has been made to put into practicable legal shape the aspirations of advanced political reformers. Its provisions include the following points:-· ADULT SuFFRAGE. RESTRICTION ON USE OF CONVEYMINIMUM RESIDENTIAL QUALIFICA-ANCES. TION. PAYMENT OF ALL ELECTION Ex- EFFICIENT QUARTERLY REGISTRA-PENSES, AND OF NEARLY ALL THE TION BY PAID OFFICERS. NECESSARY COST OF CANDIDATURE. ALTERNATIVE VOTE. pAYMENT OF MEMBERS, AND OF THEIR SIMULTANEOUS ELECTIONS. TRAYELLING EXPENSES. ABOLITION OF PLURAL VOTING. QUINQUENNIAL PARLIAMENTS. EXTENSION OF THE HOURS OF POLLING. To make a complete Reform Bill, provision should also be made for the establishment of equal electoral districts, automatically re-adjusted according to population after every census; for the consolidation of the eighty-five statutes dealing with the disqualification of candidates, and of the thirty-one dealing with the procedure at an election; for the further simplification and strengthening of the law relating to corrupt and illegal practices; and for dealing with the whole question of the House of Lords. Until the electorate consists of the whole adult population, and perfect freedom of choice of members, combined with the fullest control over their legislative action, has been secured through payment of members and their election expenses, and the alternative vote, the people will be seriously handicapped in the promotion and enactment of those measures of social reform which will ultimately result in the establishment of a properly organized community based on the socialization of industry. THE BILL. BE it enacted by the King's Most Excellent Majesty, by and with the advice and consent of the Lords Spiritual and Temporal and Commons in this present Parliament assembled and by the authorityof the same as follows: 1. This Act may be cited as the Representation of the PeopleAct, IQII. 2. This Act shall come into operation at the end of the presentparliament. Part I.-Adult Suffrage. 3. I. A uniform franchise shall be established throughout the United Kingdom and every person (including women, whether under coverture or not), save as hereinafter expressly provided, who has during four weeks preceding any registration day, namely the 5 fifteenth day of December, March, June or September, resided withio the same constituency shall be 'entitled on that registration day to. be registered as a voter, and when registered to vote at any parliamentary, municipal, county, or other public election held under the provisions of any statute within the area in which he is resident. 2. No person shall be entitled to be registered as a voter or to vote if he (I) is an infant or an alien ; or (2) is a lunatic within the meaning of the Lunacy Act~ I89o; or (3) has been convicted of a corrupt or illegal practice and has been declared incapacitated for voting during the period of such incapacity. 4!. No person shall be entitled to be registered as a voter, or when registered to vote, other than a person duly qualified . under section three of this Act, and, save as herein provided, all the Acts conferring franchises and disqualifying persons as electors are herebyrepealed. Registratt'on. 5. For the purposes of this Act the following persons shall be the local registration officers and deputy registration officers. Registration Officer Deputy Registration Officer a. In every administrative The Clerk of the County One person for each county county Council parliamentary constituency to be appointed bythe County Council b. In every county borough The Town Clerk None returning not more than one member to Parliament, and in every non-county borough returning one member to parliament c. In every county and The Town Clerk One person for each parlinon- county borough amentary division to be returning two or more appointed by the Bormembers to Parlia-ough Council ment d. In every group of bor-The Town Clerk of a The Town Clerk of everyoughs returning a borough selected by the other borough in the member to parliament Local Gov'ment Board group for his county 6. 1. On or before the last day of December, March, June, and September in each year every local registration officer shall either himself or by his deputy prepare and publish lists supplementary to. the previous final list (I} of all persons not included in the previousfinal list who shall have resided for a period of four weeks next preceding the fifteenth day of December, March, June, and Septemberrespectively within the constituency and are not disqualified as aforesaid, (2) of all persons included in the previous final list who. have not resided in the constituency during the said four weeks. 6 2. Such lists shall be classified according to locality and shall be prepared in such form and published in such manner as the Local Government Board shall prescribe. 3· It shall be the duty of every person who is rated for the relief of the poor or for any other purpose in respect of the ownership or occupation of any dwelling house or tenement to supply the local registration officer or his deputy at his request with every information within his power respecting the names and addresses of all such persons of twenty-one years of age or over as may have resided in his dwelling house or tenement for the period of four weeks next preceding the fifteenth day of December, March, June, and September respectively. 4· Any person who shall refuse or negligently omit to supply such information when so requested, or who shall wilfully or negligently give false or inaccurate information, shall, upon summary conviction, be liable to a fine not exceeding fifty pounds or to imprisonment, with or without hard labor, for a term not exceeding ·one month. 7. Any person may, on or before the tenth day of January, April, july, or October, as the case may be, by notice in writing to the local registration officer, object to the name of any person being upon the register on the ground that he is not entitled under this Act to be registered as a voter. 8. Any person entitled under this ..\.ct to be registered as a voter and whose name is not in the previous final list or on the first supplementary list may, on or before the tenth day of January, April, July, or October, as the case may be, by notice in writing to the local registration officer, claim to be registered as a voter. 9. I. On receipt of an objection the, local registration officer shall forthwith give notice thereof by post to the person objected to, stating the ground of the objection and the name and address of the person making the objection. 2. A list of names and addresses of the persons objected to and the ground of the objection and a list of the persons claiming to be registered shall be published on or before the fifteenth day of January, April, July, or October respectively by the local registration officer in such manner as the Local Government Board shall prescribe. 10. The office of revising barrister is hereby abolished. 11. The registrar of the county court exercising jurisdictionwithin the constituency or, if there be more than one county court, -of such county court as the Horne Office may appoint, or the deputy of such registrar, shall sit and shall determine all objections and claims as soon as may be and within one month after the twentieth -day of January, April, July, or October respectively. Any person 7 aggrieved by the decisions of the registrar may appeal to the judge of the county court, whose decision shall be final, save by leave of the judge or of the High Court. A person objected to or claiming to be registered may appe3l by any other person appointed in writing on that behalf before the registrar and the judge. No fees shall be charged in such proceedings, and no costs shall be awarded to either party unless it shall appear to the judge that a claim or an o!:>jection is not bona fide made. 12. The decision of a registrar shall, pending appeal under section eleven of this Act, be regarded as a final decision. 13. On the twenty-second day of February, May, August, and November in each year every local registration office shall print and publish, in such manner as the Local Government Board may prescribe, lists of electors, classified according to locality, and preparedin such form as the Local Government Board shall prescribe. Such lists shall contain the names of all persons on the previous final list or on the first supplementary list, except those on the second supplementary lisL or successfully objected to before the registrar or judge, and the names of all persons who have successfully established cbims before the registrar or judge, and such lists shall be deemed to be final lists and to be conclusive evidence, until the due publication of the next quarterly final list, of the right of any person whose name appears on such final lists to vote at any election within the constituency for which he is declared in any such list to be entitled to vote. Expenses. Hi. Save as herein expressly provided, one half of the expensesinvolved in carrying out the provisions of this Act shall be defrayed out of moneys provided by parliament in the form of a grant to the councils of counties and boroughs exercising powers under this Act, and such expenses as are not defrayed ou't of such grant shall be paid, in the case of a county, out of the county fund, and in the case of a borough out of the borough fund or rate, and the apportioningof all such expenses, whether for parliamentary or municipal purposes, shall be decided by the Local Gove·rnment Board, whose decision on such questions shall be final. 15. No grant shall be payable under section fourteen of this Act to the council of any county or borough which has not, in the opinion of the Local Government Board efficiently exercised its powers under this Act. Plural Voting. 16. Any person who shall vote more than once in the United Kingdom at one general parliamentary election or at any two or more bye-elections holden on the same day, or who shall vote more than once in the same constituency for any county, municipal, or other public election held under the provisions of any statute shall be guilty of a misdemeanor, aml, on being convicted thereof, shalt be liable to imprisonment for any term not exceeding one year, with or without hard labor. The present arrangements for registering the crowded dwellers in populous cities· are virtually those which sufficed when the Statute of Henry VI. for the first time restricted the county franchise to forty shilling freeholders. The electoral registration of London's five million inhabitants is left to no better organization than that of a rural· hamlet of the last century. At present only one in seven and a half of London's population is on the register,. as compared with one in six of the United Kingdom outside London, and one in five in many provincial boroughs. The term of occupation is absurdly long, and so arbitrarily dated, that a large number of removals in London practically involve from. eighteen months to two years disfranchisement. This part supersedes the cumbrous mass of legal technicalities contained in thirteen Acts of Parliament, and makes the work of registration as simple, economical, and nearly automatic as possible. The present interval of more than four months· between the date of claim and the date on which the register comes into force is reduced to rather over two months. The disabilities of women and peers of parliament are removed. Adult suffrage is enacted, with the minimum term of residence neces-· sary for the purposes of registration. Under the existing Registration Acts the work of registration, which is only done once a year, commences in April or May, and is not concluded till October 12th, which is the last day for the holding of the Revision Court. Under such a scheme as that proposed, the register would be made upfour times a year, and the four registrations would cost little more to prepare- than the one list under existing regulations. The individual voter is relieved of trouble and expense in claiming and supporting his claim, and provision is· made for the punishment of misconduct or wilful neglect on the part of the registration officers. The existing system of revision of the voters' lists is abolished, and a saving effected in the item of revising barristers' salaries in England of £25,000 a year. The work of preparing the register is transferred to the county and boroughcouncils. There will be only one register for all elections, local as well as parliamentary. Part 11.-Elections. Candidates. 17. Save as in this Act expressly provided, all elections shall take place at the time and in the manner now provided by parliament. 18. 1. Save as hereinafter provided, any person not disqualified' under section three, sub-section two, of this Act, for being an elector may be a candidate at any election. 2. Provided that no person who has, within two years of any registration day, been convicted, either on indictment or summarily, of any crime and sentenced to imprisonment with hard labor without the option of a fine, or to any greater punishment,. and has not receiYed a free pardon, or has, within or during the time aforesaid been adjudged bankrupt, or made a composition or arrangement with his creditor~, and not received his discharge, shall be qualified to be a candidate at any election. 19. No peer of parliament shall, so long as he is a duly elected member of the House of Commons, be entitled to sit or vote in the House of Lords. 9 Returning O!Jiars. 20. For the purposes of this Act the local registration officer shall be the returning officer for all elections held within his constituency, and the salary of every local registration officer shall be deemed to include his expenses as returning officer, and all fees and charges of returning officers shall be abolished. O!Jicial Poll Card. 21. The returning officer in every constituency shall, three days. before the day of any election, forward by post to every elector an official poll card, showing the names of the candidates, the number of the elector on the register, and the place at which he is entitled to poll. Such poll cards shall be transmitted through the Post Office and delivered free of charge. 22. The returning officer in every constituency shall, within three days of the date of nomination, cause to be printed and postedin convenient places throughout the constituency an official placard showing the names of all the candidates, the date of the poll, and the polling places assigned to each district. Free Electzim Addresses. 23. Every candidate may at his nomination deliver to the returning officer a copy of his election address, which shall not exceed five thousand words in length. The returning officer shall haye all such election addresses printed, and shall deliver to the Post Office a packet directed to each registered elector in the constituency containing copies of all such addresses. The Post Office shall transmit and deliver such packets free of charge. Free Postage of Electzim Lz'terature. 24i. Every candidate may once between his nomination and the day of election deliver to the returning officer a packet of literature for each elector, folded and addressed in accordance with the regulations of the Post Office relating to inland letters and not exceeding four ounces in weight. The returning officer shall deliver such packets to the Post Office and the Post Office shall deliver them to the addressees free of charge. In the States of Oregon and Montana, where the Initiative and Referendum are used for State legislation, the voters are "instructed by means of literature furnished by those initiating or opposing a measure and distributed by the Secretary of State" (Political Scimce Quarterly, December, rgo8). Free Use of Schoolroom. 25. I. A candidate at any election may use, free of charge, for the purpose of public meetings during the period of an election, anysuitable room in any school receiving a grant out of moneys provided by parliament, and any suitable room in any building, the expense of maintaining which is wholly or partially payable out of IO any local rate ; provided that three days' notice of the proposedpublic meeting be given to the authority responsible for such school or building. 2. The use of the school or building shall be granted in the order of the receipt of the application by or on behalf of the candidates, provided that no candidate shall have the use of the same hall or room on a second occasion should any other candidate desire the use of it for the first time. Hours ifPoll£ng. 26. At every election the poll (if any) shall commence at eighto'clock in the forenoon and be kept open till ten o'clock in the afternoon of the same day. 27. The Local Government Board shall provide an adequatenumber of ballot boxes for each constituency, materials for voters to mark the ballot papers, and all forms, other than ballot papers, required for use at an election, and shall supply them, free of charge, within ten days of the receipt of the requisition of the returningofficer for the constituency in which they are to be used. 28. The returning officer shall furnish all ballot papers and all forms of nomination of candidates at a parliamentary election, and shall provide each polling station with copies of the register of voters, or such parts thereof as contain the names of the voters allotted to vote at such station, for use by the presiding officer and the persona· tion agents of each candidate. Max£mum Expenses. 29. One half of the maximum expenses mentioned in Parts I., II., and III. of the First Schedule of the Corrupt and Illegal Practices Prevention Act, 1883, shall be substituted for the maximum amounts contained in Part IV. of the First Schedule of that Act. S£multaneous Elect£ons. 30. All writs issued by the Clerk to the Crown to the returningofficers of constituencies at a general election of members to parliament shall bear the same date and shall on that date be issued. The returning officer of every parliamentary constituency shall appoint the day for the nomination of candidates to be not later than the fourth day after the day on which he receives the writ, and the day for taking the poll to be the third Saturday after the date on which the writ is issued. The cost of a general election, even under the restricted scale of the Corrupt and Illegal Practices Prevention Act (r883), is still such a tax on the candidates as tore- establish for some purposes the property qualification supposed to have been abolished in rsss. In boroughs the maximum expenditure allowed for one candidate is £350, where the ~umber of electors does not exceed two thousand, and rises by £30 for every succeedmg thousand or part of a thousand electors. In counties the maximum is £650, II for two thousand electors, and £6o for each thousand or part of a thousand electors above that number. This scale does not include the returning officer's expenses, which, though limited by the Parliamentary Elections (Returning Officers) Act (r875), amounted to £25,000 in January, 1910. The total expenditure, according to the candidates' returns at the general election of 1906 was £ r,r66,858, and in that of January, I9IO, £1,296,382, including returning officer's expenses. The returning officer's expenses would be largely reduced by this part of the Act so far as his old duties are concerned, and the extra expense involved by his new duties would be minimized by having the printing, etc., done on a large scale. By clause 29 these maximum expenses are halved. The schedule of charges at present allowed would be considerably modified, and the amount of personal expenditure by the candidate reduced. By these provisions everything practicable has been done to place the poorest candidate on an equality with the richest. In no European country but the United Kingdom is the expense of printingballot papers, provision of ballot boxes, voting compartments, forms of nomination and return, travelling of presiding officers, and conveyance of boxes, etc., to the place of counting votes and declaration of the poll, placed upon the candidates. In this country the above expenses, known as "the returning officer's expenses," are at present (r9r r) divided equally between the various candidates. In France, Austria, Hungary, and Italy the payment is made entirely out of the State Exchequer. In the Netherlands, Portugal, Spain, Sweden, and Japan the burden is thrown on the local rates. In Belgium and Greece the expense is divided, the ballot boxes, desks, and permanent fixtures being provided by the State in the first instance, and stored, renewed, and repaired by the localities to which they are allotted for use. All other election expenses are paid out of the local funds. In Germany the polling expenses are defrayed locally. In Norway election to the Storthing is absolutely free of expense. Under the Act Regulating the Procedure at Parliamentary and Municipal Elections (35 & 36 Viet. c. 33), the returning officer may use, free of charge, for the purpose of taking the poll at a parliamentary election, any room in a school receiving a grant out of moneys provided by parliament, and any room the expense of maintaining which is payable out of any local rate. Any such room in a rural district can be used for parish meetings, public enquiries, meetings relating to allotments under the Small Holdings and Allotments Act, 1908, and for meetings" for the purpose of the candidature of any person for the (rural) district council or the parish council." Local Government Act, 1894, section 4· Alternative Parliamentary Vote. 31. Whenever more than two candidates are nominated for one parliamentary constituency, the following provisions shall take effect. I. Every elector shall have an ordinary vote (herein called a first vote) and an alternative vote (herein called a second vote). 2 . The ballot papers shall be printed in such a way as to allow two defined spaces for voting opposite the name of each candidate. 3· Every voter shall exercise his first vote by marking his ballot paper in the usual manner in the space marked first vote, and shall exercise his second vote by marking the same ballot paper in the usual manner in the space marked second vote. 32. I. Every vote given as a first or second vote shall be allowed or disallowed and counted in the like manner as if such a vote were a vote given at an election when not more than two candidates have been nominated. 12 2. The first votes shall be counted first, and if any candidate receive more than one half of the first votes recorded he shall be declared to be duly elected. 3· If no candidate receive more than one half of the total number of first votes recorded, the second votes recorded on those ballot papers on which the first vote has not been cast for the two candidates receiving the greatest number of first votes shall be counted, and such second votes as are thereon recorded for the two candidates receiving the greatest number of votes shall be added to the first votes recorded for such candidates, and the candidate who receives the greatest number of votes when such second votes are so added to the first votes recorded for such candidates shall be and be declared to be duly elected. 4· If no candidate receive more than one half of the total number of first votes recorded, and one, two, or more candidates who receive the highest number of first votes after the candidate who receives the highest number of votes receive an equal number of first votes, the second votes recorded on those ballot papers in which one first vote has been recorded for any candidate receiving less votes than the candidates so receiving an equal number of votes shall be counted, and such second votes shall be added to the votes of the candidates so receiving an equal number of votes, and the candidate who receives the greatest number of votes shall be deemed to be one of the two candidates receiving the greatest number of votes under sub-section three of this section, and thereupon the counting of votes shall proceed and the result of the election be ascertained as in that sub-section provided. 5· If no candidate receive more than one half of the total number of first votes recorded, and the two or more candidates who receive the highest number of first votes after the candidate who receives the highest number of votes receive an equal number of votes, and there are no candidates receiving less votes than such candidates receiving equal votes, the second votes recorded on those ballot papers on which the first vote has been recorded for the candidates receiving equal votes shall be counted and such second votes shall be added to the votes of the candidates so receiving an equal number of votes, and the candidate who receives the greatest number of votes shall be deemed to be one of the candidates receiving the greatest number of votes under sub-section three of this section, and thereupon the counting of votes shall proceed and the result of the election be ascertained as in that sub-section provided. Our A11tiquated System.-" The • relative majority' single-member method is in force, besides the United Kingdom, in the United States, Denmark (for the Lower House), Bulgaria and Greece. "The Stcond Ballot.-The Second Ballot exists in Austria-Hungary, France, Germany (both for the Reichstag and in most of the States), Italy, the Netherlands, orway, Roumania, Russia. Servia (for single-member districts), and Switzerland (for the Federal Council). "In France, Norway, Roumania, Russia, and Switzerland all the candidates at a first ballot may stand again at the second, where a relatively small majority suffices ; I~.) in the other countries all candidates are eliminated from the second ballot except the two who. received the largest number of vates.at the first. "In some countries a provision is added that a candidate must receive at the first ballot not only an absolute majority of the votes cast, but also a number of votes equal to a definite proportion (one quarter in France, one-sixth in Italy) of the registered electors. "The intervals between the two elections are frequently fixed by law. Thus, in France the second ballot takes place on the second Sunday after the first-i.e., a fortnight, as elections are always held on Sundays; in Italy, after an interval of not less than four or more than eight days." (Royal Commission, mfra, 1910, p. so.) THE ALTERNATIVE VOTE. Second ballot is the usual method for determining an election when three or more candidates stand for one seat, and its advantages are obvious, because it prevents the election of a candidate who is voted for by a minority of the actual voters. Our present system-also the rule in the United States and in nearly all the British Dominions-which only allows one ballot, forces compromise before the election, or splits between the various groups or parties which support the ministry or the opposition, with the result that the seat may go to the most solid and not to the most numerous section. The presence of an active and important third party in English politics, the Labor Party, makes some form of second ballot imperative.* The alternative vote here proposed is strongly advocated by the Royal Commission appointed to enquire into Electoral Systems in their Report of 1910, signed by Lord Richard Cavendish, the Hon. W. Pember Reeves, Sir Courtenay Ilbert, and others. It has precisely the same result as second ballot where there are two or three candidates for one seat, and will have nearly the same result in other cases. It has the great advantage of not involving the delay, expense, and trouble of a second ballot after an interval of a fortnight; it does not give opportunity for bargaining in the interval between the two ballots, a practice likely to lead to objectionable compromises ; and it practically prevents small third or fourth parties deciding a contest on illegitimate grounds. Under second ballot, if the votes were A 1,400. B 8oo, C 700, D 200, and assuming that B and C were closely allied parties, their joint vote should carry the seat. But D could give the victory to either side, and might easily do so for reasons which may be vaguely termed illegitimate. The alternative vote practically prevents this, because no one could foresee the result of a complicated election with sufficient certainty to justify bargaining. The alternative vote has been in operation in Queensland since the Electoral Act of 1892 and in Western Australia since the Electoral Act of 1907. PROPORTIONAL REPRESENTATION. We do not propose this widely advertised scheme of reform of our electoral system for reasons admirably set forth in the report of the commission alreadyreferred to. If parliament had merely to discuss and consult, a method of election which gave every section representation in proportion to its numbers would have much to recommend it. But, in fact, parliament has to legislate, and through its executive, the cabinet, to administer our home affairs and to conduct foreign and colonial policy. For these purposes a method of elecion which accentuates the majority at any givt'ntime is actually preferable to a method which accurately represents it. Weak governments are the worst governments, because they do least work and do it badly. When the electorate is divided, as it often is, in the proportion (say) of nineteen votes on one side to twenty on the other, it is for the advantage of the nation that the parliament returned by those votes should be in the proportion of fourteen to twenty-five. *.The case against it, even under the present system, is stated by Mr. J. RamsayMacDonald in his "Socialism and Government," though, on the whole, he decides that a change is necessary. The arguments against proportional representation are that it would involve large constituencie;, not less than ten times the size of our present ones. The cost of elections would be enormously increased, and the difficulty of candidates makingthemselves and their opinions known to their constituents would be aggravated. ln the old London School Board elections the parties had to meet this by dividing the large constituencies then in u~e into districts and allotting the parts to the several candidates, who devoted themselves to these districts only, and invited the electors thereof to give them all their votes. The very heavy cost of these elections would increase the advantage which wealthy candidates and parties already have over those with less money at their disposa l. Other objections are the impossibility of devising any satisfactory method of conducting bye elections under a system of proportional representation, and the fact that the expected result, the election of two or more large parties very nearly balanced and a few nondescripts representing special sections or, through their outstanding personalities, representing, in fact, themsel ves, would give the balance of power, the decision as to the policy of the nation, into the hands of a group of these small, incompatible minorities, such as, at the present moment, Free-Trade Unionists, the Anti-Socialist Radicals, the Anti-Romanists, the Liberal Unionists, the Anti-Labor-Party Socialists, the \Vomen Suffragists, the Independent Nationalists, and the other often estimable, but peculiar, 1•oliticians who usually represent worn out creeds or else political parties not yet in being. Lastly, the difficulties of the imperfectly educated voter would be enormously increased. Instead of having to vote for one of two or, at most (except in rare cases), three candidates, he would be required to select ten names out of a list of twenty, at least, and twenty-five, thirty, forty, or even more in other cases. Chance, notoriety for quite irrelevant reasons, and numerous other factors would come into play. Numbers of persons \\Ould be returned to parliament not to represent a delinite political policy or a particular view held by a small section, but because they bore a well known name, or owned a Derby winner, or had a son who played in the countycricket eleven or the borough football club. For these and other reasons set out in the Report of the Royal Commis;ion above referred to, and also cogently stated by Mr. j. Ramsay MacDonald in his "Socialism and Government." we think that no system of proportional representation yet im·ented could be adopted without gravely impairing effective democratic control. Proportional representation is in operation in Belgium, Denmark, Finland, Sen•ia, Sweden, Switzerland (in eight cantons), Tasmania, and \VUrtembe•g. 33. 1. No con\'eyance or horse or other animal shall be let, lent, or employed by any person for the purpose of con\'eying any other person, except a bona fide member of his own household, to or from the poll, except as provided in section 14 (3) of the Corrupt and Illegal Practices Pre,·ention Act, 1883. 2. Any person who shall so let, lend, or employ .1 conyeyance or horse or other animal contrary to the provisions of this section shall, on summary c01wiction, be liable to a fine not exceding £100. The section above named pe• mils an elector or several electors at their joint cost to hire a public stage or hackney carriage for the purpooe of being com·eyed to or from the poll. Part 111.-Parliament. 3~. J. Each of the parliamentary boroughs returning lii'O members to parliament shall for the purpose ot returning members to erYe for such borough in parliament be divided into divisions. Ij 2. The number, names, contents, and boundaries of such divisions respectively shall be those specified by the Local Government Board. 35. No university or group of universi ties shall return a member or members to serve for such university or group of universities in parliament. 36. I. Every member duly elected to parliament, who has duly taken the oath required to be taken by members of parliament, or who has duly made affirmation in lieu thereof in the manner required by law, shall from the time of taking such oath or making such affirmation, so long as he remains a member of any parliament, be entitled to a salary of three hundred pounds per annum, which salary shall be paid out of moneys provided by parliament. 2. Every such member shall likewise be entitled to an allowance, to be paid out of moneys provided by parliament, for travel- ling expenses at the following rate, namely, when in the opinion of the Speaker : a. The furthest boundary of the constituency is over 500 miles from the Palace of Westminster: ;{100 per annum. b. The furthest boundary of the constituency is over 250 miles, but not over soo miles, from the Palace of Vvestminster: £75 per annum. c. The furthest boundary of the constituency is 2 50 miles or under from the Palace of Westminster: £so per annum. 37. Five years shall be substituted for seven years as the time fixed for the maximum duration of parliament under the Septennial Act, 1715. Prior to the Revolution of 1688, with the exception of a few years during the Commonwealth, the duration of parliaments was entirely within the control of the Sovereign. Une of the parliaments of Charles II. sat eighteen years. The Triennial Act was passed in 1694. Its preamble declares " that frequent and new parliamentstend very much to the happy union and good agreement of King and people." The Septennial Act, one of the earliest measures of the first parliament of George 1., was nominally based on a desire to relieve the country of the "grievous and burdensome" expense of elections, and also from ''the violent and lasting heats and animosities among the subjects of the realm," but was really aimed at the "restless and Popishfaction," which was "designing and endeavoring to renew the Rebellion within this Kingdom and an invasion from abroad." The dangers of 1714 have passed away, and the Septennial Act should therefore have been repealed more than a century and a half ago, but all attempts at repeal have been unsuccessful. Parliaments rarely last longer than five years, and the average length is considerably less. A legislative assembly of the Union of South Africa may sit for five years; the House of Representatives of the Australio.n Commonwealth for three years, and these are among the newest parliaments created. The German Reichstag is elected for five years. The proposal to pay members of parliament is not an untried and new-fangled innovation, but a reversion to old constitutional custom, both in England and Scot land. "The custom began," says Dr. Henry, in his work ''Greater Britain," ''with the commencement of representation from a principle of common equity." In Scotland the payment was made in accord~nce with the terms of a statute. dated. 1427, which has been' preserved, and is supposed to have been copied from an English statute that has been lost. Professor Thorold Rogers says that in the reign of Edward I. "the member of parliament had daily wages; the knights or county members receiving more-the amount is not invariable-than the burgesses. When the parliament was prorogued or dismissed, the writs for payment were made out, and the time during which the house sat exactly calculated." A judgment of Lord Chancellor Nottingham after the dissolution of parliament in 1681 proves that the payment was not merely a voluntary contribution by the constituencies. Thomas King, M.P. for Harwich, presented a petition stating "that he had served as burge~se in parliamentfor the said borrough severall yeares, and did give his constant attendance therein; but that the said borrough had not paid him his wages, though often requested so to do." Notice being given to the Corporation of Harwich and the facts being verified, a writ was ordered to be issued, de expensis burgensium levandis. This was probablythe last order so made. "I know no reason," said Lord Campbell, commenting on this judgment, "in point of law why any member may not insist on payment of his wages. For this point in the People's Charter-payment of wages-no ne\'1' law is required." An Act of 1541 made the payment of wages depend upon attendance in the house throughout the whole session. Payment of members is required to enable constituencies to choose freely their representatives, to give the public complete control over them, and to compel them to perform their duties with diligence and efficiency. The poor candidate would thus be put upon an equality with the richest. An equitable and convenient adjustment of burdens is made by the payment of members out of the state, and the election expenses out of the local, exchequers. Payment of members is the law in almost every country where representative government prevails. A table of existing laws on the subject will be found opposite. The declaration of Mr. Asquith, in November, 1910, as Prime Minister and Leader of the Liberal Party, to the effect that payment of members and payment of election expenses would be established in 19II, if he was again returned to power, makes clause 36 the first likely to be adopted at Westminster. Clause 37 is the last clause of the Parliament Bill, 1910. LIST OF BOOKS. KING, J.-Electoral Reform: an Enquiry into our System of Parliamentary Representation. 1908. Unwin. 2s. 6d. net. MACDONALD, ]. R.-Socialism and Government. 1909. I.L.P., 23 Bride Lane, E.C. 2s. and 3s. net. Report of Royal Commission on Electoral Systems. Cd. 5163, 1910. 6~d. Reports from His Majesty's Representatives in Foreign Countries and in British Colonies respecting the Application of the Principle of Proportional Representation to Public Elections. Cd. 350I. 1907. Is. 3d. 17 Table of Existing Laws as to Payment of Membe,.s of Legislatu,.es. PAYMENT TO MEMBERS OF CouNTRY. OTHER ALLOWANCES. LEGISLATURE. AUSTRIA ... r6s. Sd. per day while the House is in Travelling expenses paidsession. BELGIUM ... Deputies receive 4,000 francs (£r6o) Free travelling on State per year. railways. Free travelling on private railways between residence aud capital. BAVARIA ... Members of Upper House are unpaid. Free railway travellingDeputies receive res. per day during during session and session. eight days before and after. BULGARIA Members of National Assembly living in capital receive I2s. per day duringsession ; members resident out of capital receive r6s. per day, which includes travelling expenses. Members receive rrs. rd. per day dur- DENMARK Free railway travellinging the first six months of the session (second class). and 6s. Sd. per day for every additional day. Senators and deputies receive £6oo per FRANCE ... An annual payment of year. £2 entitles members of both Chambers to tra\'el free on all railways. Members of the Reichstag receive £1 so GERMANY Free railway travelling per year. A sum of £r is deducted during session. for each day's absence. Deputies are paid £72 for each ordi- Free railway and steam- nary session. For an extraordinary GREECE ... ship travelling duringsession only travelling expenses are se,sion. allowed, but reimbursements for ex tra expenses, \'arying from £6o to £So, are general! y voted. Members of the Lower House receive £zoo per year, with £66 I 3s. for house rent. HUNGARY ~!embers are not paid. Free railway travelling and postage. ITALY Members of the First Chamber notre· Free rai lway travelling. siding at the Hague are paid 16s. Sd. per day whi le in session. Members of the econd Chamber receive £166 per year. NETHERLANDS 18 PAYMENT TO MEMBERS OF OTHER ALLOWANCES. COUNTRY. LEGISLATURE. Travelling expenses as I 3s. 4d. per day during session. All members of the Storthing receive NoRWAY ... follows: 2~d. per kilometre for pony or cariole. sd. per kilometre for rowboats. r£d. per kilometre for train. sd. per sea mile for steamers. Free medical attendance during session. Funeral expenses paid if member dies during session. Colonial deputies receive £20 per month while the Cortes is sitting and £ro per month at other times. Ordinary deputies have been unpaidsince 1892. PORTUGAL Members receive Iss. per day during PRUSSIA se~sion. Deputies receive r6s. 8d. per day of ac· Free railw3y travelling. tual attendance during session. ROUMANIA Elective members of the Council of the Free railway travellingEmpire receive during the session RuSSIA to and from St. Peters£ z 13s. per day. burg. Members of the Duma receive £r 13s. per day during the session. Members of both Houses resident in capital receive 6s. per day duringthe session. Other members receive I2s. per dayand travelling allowance. SAXONY ..• Deputies receive 12s. per day during Travelling allowance. session. SERVIA Neither senators nor deputies are paid. SPAIN Members of both Chambers receive Travelling expenses paid £66 for each session of four months and 1 Is. per day for an extra se,sion. Travelling expenses paid SWEDEN Members of the National Council and SWITZERLAND.. at rate of 20 centimes Council of States receive r6s. 8d. per per kilometre (2~d. day during session. per mile) ...-. UNITED STATES All members of Congress receive $7,500 T ravelling allowance of (£r.sco) per year. 20 cents (red.) per mile. 19 COUNTRY. UNITED STATES ( coutimted) WURTDIIJERG CAXADA . .. . -\USTilALIAN Co~IMONWLTH VICTO!UA ... QUEENSLAND NEw SO UTH WALES SOUTH TRALI.-\ Aus- WESTERN TRALIA Aus- TASMANIA NEw ZEALAND PAYMENT TO MEMBERS OF LEGI SLATURE. Members of both Chambers receive rss. per day. Men:bers of Senate and House of Commons receive £500 each ses£ion of more than 30 days. If ses;ion lasts IP.ss than thirty days,£+ per day is paid. The leader of the opposition receives £1,400 per year extra. Members receive £6oo per ye3r. Members of Legislative Council (Upper ' House) are unpaid. Members of Legislative Assembly (Lower House) receive £300 per year. Ditto Ditto Ditto Ditto Members of each House receive £200 per year. Ditto Ditto Members of each Hou2e recei\'e £roo per year. Members of Legislative Council (Upper House) rec"ive £zoo per year. Members of House of Representatives (Lower House) receive £300 per year. OTHER ALLOWANCES. Senators allowed $2,000 (£400) per year for clerical assistance ; congressmen allowed $r.sco (£3co) per year. Ali members allowed $rzs (£zs) per yearfor stationery. Free postage. Private room (furnished, lighted, and heated free) provided in Congressiona I official building for each member. Free seed samples from Agricultural Depart· ment for farmer constituents, etc. Free railway travelling. Travelling expenses paid Free tra\'elling on Government railways. Ditto Ditto Ditto Ditto Ditto Ditto Ditto DittO Ditto Ditto Ditto Ditto Ditto Ditto UJ•em.en•·slnn, London, W.O. FABIAN ESSAYS IN SOCIALISM. New Preface by BBBNABD SHAW, Paper 6d. net; cloth I/6; postage 2~d. and 4d. WHAT TO READ on Social and Economic Subjects. Fifth edition, revised to October, 1910, and enlarged. Interleaved, paper, IS. n. cloth 2s. n., post. 2d. THIS MISERY OF BOOTS. By H . G. WELLS. 3d., post free 4d. TRACT INDEX AND CATALOGUE RAISONNE. 3d. FABIAN TRACTS and LEAFLETS. Tiacta, each 16 to 52 pp., pt"ice 1d., or 9d. per do•., unleaa otherwiautaled, Leaflets, 4 pp. each, price ld.for aiz copies, 1a . per 100, or 8/6 per 1000, The Set ot 78, 3s.; post free 3/5· Bound in. Buckram, 4/6 n.; post free 511. I.-General Socialism in its various aspects. TBAOTS.-ISI. The Point of Honour: a Correspondence on Aristocracy and Socialism. By RUTH CAVENDISH BENTINCK. I47· Capital and Compensation. By EDW. R. PEASE. I46. Socialism and Superior Brains. A reply to Mr. Mallock. By BERNARD SHAW. I42. Rent and Value. I38. Municipal Trading. I2I. Public Service versus Private Expenditure. By Sir 0LIVEB LODGE. 113. Communism. ByWM. MOBBIS. I07. Socialism for Millionaires. By BEBNARD SHAW. I39· Socialism and the Churches. By Rev. JOHN CLIFFORD, D.D I33· Socialism and Christianity. By Rev. PERCY DEARMER (in cover with portrait of the author). 78. Sociaism and the Teaching of Christ. By Dr. J. CLIFFOBD. 42. Christian Socialism. By Rev. S.D. HEADLAM. 79· A Word of Remembrance and Caution to the Rich. By JoHN WooLMAN. 75· Labor in the Longest Reign. By S. WEBB. 72. The Moral Aspects of Socialism. By SIDNEY BALL. 6g. Difficulties of Individualism. By SIDNEY WEBB. 51. Socialism: True and False. By S. WEBB. 45· The Impossibilities of Anarchism. ByBEBNABD SHAW (price 2d.). 7· Capital and Land (7th edn. revised 1908). S· Factf for Socialists (11th ed., revised 1908). I32. A Guide to Books for Socialists. LEAFLETS-I3. What Socialism Is. I. Why are the Many Poor? WELSH TRACTS-I43· Sosialaeth yng Ngoleuni'r Beibl. Gan J . R. JONES (Caernarfon). I4I. Translation of 139. 87. Translation of 78. 38. Translation of 1. U.-Applications of Socialism to Particular Problems. TBAOTS.-I52. Our Taxes as they are and as they ought to be. By RoBT. J oNES, B.Sc. In cover, 2d. ISO. State Purchase of Railways. By E MIL DAVIES. In cover, 2d. I49· The Endowment of Motherhood. By H. D. HABBEN. In cover, 2d. I45· The Case for School Nurseries. By Mrs. TowNSHEND. I44· Machinery : its Masters and its Servants. By H. H. SCHLOESSER and C. GAME. I40. Child Labor under Capitalism. By Mrs. H YLTON DALE. I36. The Village and the Landlord. By EDw. CARPENTEB. I3I. The Decline in the Birth-Rate. By S. WEBB. I30. Home Work and Sweating. By Miss B.L. HuTCHINS. 128. The Case for a Legal Minimum Wage. I22. Municipal Milk and Public Health. By Dr. F . LAWSON DoDD. 125. Municipalization by Provinces. ug. Public Control of Electrical Power and Transit. 123. The Revival of Agriculture. 118. The Secret of Rural Depopulation. 115. State Aid to Agriculture: an Example. 112. Life in the Laundry. 98. State Railways for Ireland. I24. State Control of Trusts. 86. Municipal Drink Traffic. 84. Economics of Direct Employment. 83. State Arbitration and the LivingWage. LEAFLET.-I04· How Trade Unions benefit Workmen. IlL-Local Government Powers: How to use them. TBACTS.-I37· Parish Councils and Village Life. I09. Cottage Plans and Common Sense. By RAYMOND UNWIN. 76. Houses for the People. 99· Local Government in Ireland. 82. Workmen's Compensation Act. New edition for the Act of 1906. 62. Parish and District Councils. 54· The Humanizing of the Poor Law. By J. F. OAKEBHOTT. LEAFLETS.I34 ·Small Holdings, Allotments and Common Pastures: and how to getthem. 20. Questions for Poor Law Guardians. 68. The Tenant's Sanitary Catechism. 71. Ditto for London. FABIAN MUNICIPAL LEAFLETS (Nos. 32, 37 and go to 93), Municipalization of the Gas Supply. A Labor Policy for Public Authorities. Municipalization of Milk Supply. Municipal Pawnshops. Municipal Slaughterhouses. Women as Councillors. 11-per 100. IV. General Politics and Fabian Policy. I27· Socialism and Labor Policy. 116. Fabianism and the Fiscal Question : an alternative policy. I08. Twentieth Century Politics. BySIDNEY WEBB. 70. R eport on Fabian Policy. 41. The Fabian Society, its Early History. By Bl!:BNARD SHAW. !'nutcd by 0. Stundrlu::, 7 Finsbury :St .. London, E.G., ""d pnhlished by tbc Fabi•n t:!oc.cty, 3 Clement's Inn, Strand, London, \V.C.